Marywood Secular Student Alliance denied, school newspaper publishes article

Marywood University’s student newspaper published an article detailing my efforts to start a Secular Student Alliance group at Marywood University.

Marywood denied my motion to start this club.
Here is the text of the article:

A new group that has been denied approval as an official club is stirring controversy on campus due to its nature.

The Marywood University Secular Student Alliance (MUSSA), led by Justin Vacula, a first-year mental health counseling graduate student, recently went before Student Activities and Campus Ministry seeking university approval and club status.


According to MUSSA’s Facebook group page, which was launched on January 29, the mission of the alliance is “to provide a community for secular individuals…foster discussion about topics relating to ethics, the separation of church and state, supernatural and paranormal beliefs; work with other local secular groups; and to present a positive and accurate view of secular individuals to the community at large.”

Vacula met with Carl Oliveri, director of student activities and leadership development, and Sr. Catherine Luxner, director of Campus Ministry, to discuss his proposed organization. Vacula said that Oliveri and Luxner denied MUSSA club status for various reasons, the most prominent being that it the club’s mission conflicts with “the Catholic identity of Marywood.”
According to the Student Activities web page, all clubs “must adhere to the Mission Statements of Marywood University… the Center for Student Activities and Leadership Development, [and] the Core Values of Marywood University.” In addition to one of Marywood’s Core Values being “Catholic Identity,” its Mission Statement states that it “challenges students to make decisions based on spiritual, ethical, and religious values.”

However, Vacula argued that the Mission Statement can be interpreted in a way that would support a student organization for atheists.  That part reads:  “Marywood offers…a welcoming and supportive community that encourages men and women of all backgrounds to shape their lives as leaders in service to others.”

He also cited the part of the Catholic Identity Statement, which he argues supports the mission of MUSSA: “The University welcomes people of all religious and humanistic traditions to participate in [open respectful dialogue] so as to arrive at truth.”

Despite the fact that not everyone who attends the university is Catholic or even a follower of any faith, Oliveri said he feels that its religious affiliation sets it apart.

“This is Marywood; it’s a private Catholic institution. It’s a lot different than a public institution or a community college,” said Oliveri.

But, Vacula argued that regardless of its Catholic identity, Marywood is still an institution of higher learning which should be promoting diversity.  “[The administration] should be accepting of a group like this because higher education is about considering ‘big questions,’ encountering foreign ideas, and challenging one’s own beliefs. Being a Catholic campus is all the more reason for a club like this to exist on campus,” said Vacula.

Other clubs, like the Ally Club, an organization for gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgendered, and questioning students, have been recognized and funded, though it is well-known that the Catholic church condemns homosexuality.  Vacula cited this club as another reason MUSSA should be granted approval.

Vacula said Oliveri and Luxner also argued that there aren’t many students who would be interested in MUSSA. However, Vacula said that he knows of many secular students on campus. The MUSSA Facebook group had 12 student members at press time, though Vacula said he suspects many more exist but withhold their identity for fear of alienation.

“Negative stereotypes and general misunderstanding exists surrounding secular individuals, so this club would be a good opportunity to correct those stereotypes and misunderstandings. We want to present an accurate depiction of what non-theists are like. Atheists don’t think people who are religious are stupid or misinformed,” Vacula said.

Even though MUSSA has not been approved as of press time, Vacula said he is currently working on tweaking various aspects of the club in order to make it more acceptable to administration and will continue to meet with them.

According to Oliveri, there is still an open and active dialogue between Vacula, student activities and Campus Ministry.  “I’ll always listen to students, but sometimes you have to make decisions that [they] don’t want to hear and that’s just the way it is,” said Oliveri.
Vacula’s plans for MUSSA include holding two-hour bi-weekly meetings with an open discussion. He also plans to invite guest speakers and hold special events such as “Ask an Atheist.” Vacula said that while the group would be primarily for like-minded people, it is open to everyone. “[This group] shouldn’t be seen as a threat, but should be something to embrace.”

Sr. Catherine Luxner declined to comment, citing confidentiality issues.

If you’d like to support my efforts to form a club for secular students, please share this blog post and join the group’s Facebook page whether you are a Marywood student or not!

Justin Vacula

Justin Vacula hosts the Stoic Philosophy Podcast; serves as co-organizer and spokesperson for the Northeastern Pennsylvania (NEPA) Freethought Society; and has hosted monthly Stoic Philosophy discussion groups for the Humanist Association of Greater Philadelphia.

He has appeared on and hosted various radio shows and podcasts; participated in formal debates and discussions; was a guest speaker for college-level courses; was featured in local, national, and international news; and has been invited to speak at various national, local, and statewide events.

Vacula received bachelor’s degrees in Philosophy and Psychology, a minor in Professional Writing, and the distinguished W.A. Kilburn Memorial Award for Philosophy from King’s College in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania. He is currently living in the Scranton, PA area attending Marywood University’s graduate-level Mental Health Counseling program and has worked with the Arc of Luzerne County’s Transition to Community Employment program as a teacher’s assistant and job coach alongside adult learners with intellectual and developmental disabilities.

He also plays poker; volunteers as a member of the website and media team for the Greyhawk Reborn Dungeons & Dragons campaign while playing at events in the Eastern United States; and enjoys metal music.

  • Seems like Viewpoint Discrimination is illegal in a limited public forum when it’s a Government Institution which is supposed to be secular, but has to let religious clubs exist, but when it’s a Private Religious Institution, Viewpoint Discrimination is just fine and dandy and an excellent excuse to exclude Atheists or Secularists. Perhaps your club should be entitled “The Marian Outreach Club to understand the viewpoint Of Secular and Atheist Students”? … There … you have satisfied the University’s problem of having a Club with a Catholic identity and a Catholic mission! After all, the understanding of all viewpoints and promotion of harmony between students is part of their mission, is it not?

  • The major problem is atheism is not a religion nor a recognized group as it concerns American discrimination laws as they concern private universities. As a Catholic institution, they can (I believe) deny access to those who disagree with their religious teachings. In their own words, ” Marywood University is coeducational, comprehensive, residential, and Catholic.”The Church has rarely found itself in a position that it must accept opposing views. Unfortunately, this is not one of them.